Skip to main content
Topic
Guide
Published
17 Nov 2026
Reading time
7 min
By
ASODrift team

Why does AI give everyone the same app ideas? What the research says (2026)

Ask an AI assistant for app ideas a few times and the same ones keep coming back. Four published studies explain why language models converge, what it costs you on Google Play, and five ways to find ideas the average prompt never surfaces.

In this article +

Key takeaways

  1. 01Language models give the most likely answer, so open-ended questions like “give me app ideas” return the same typical ideas.
  2. 02Tuning models to be helpful narrows their range: RLHF reduced output diversity compared with supervised fine-tuning (Kirk et al., ICLR 2024).
  3. 03Switching assistants doesn’t fix it: a NeurIPS 2025 study of ~26K open-ended questions found models repeat themselves and each other.
  4. 04Everyone gains, the group loses: AI-assisted stories were more creative one by one but more alike overall (Science Advances, 2024).
  5. 05The fix is a different input, not a different prompt: start from what people search for and complain about.

Ask an AI assistant for app ideas a few times, in fresh chats, and the same ones keep coming back: a habit tracker, a budget planner, a meal planner, a journaling app with a mood chart. It feels like the assistant is out of ideas. It isn’t. It is doing what it was built to do, and researchers have now measured the effect in several different ways.

4
published studies behind this post
26K
open-ended questions in the largest of them
1%
of apps under 100 ratings reached a Google Play top 3 in our data
24%
of apps with 100,000+ ratings did

Reason 1: a language model predicts the likeliest answer

A language model writes by choosing, one word after another, what is most probable given everything it has read. Ideas that people have written about thousands of times, such as habit trackers and budget apps, are the most probable completions of “here are some app ideas”. The odd, specific, local idea that appears in a handful of forum posts is far less likely, so it rarely wins. Asking again doesn’t help much: the same probabilities are being sampled.

Reason 2: tuning for helpful answers narrows the range

Raw models are then tuned to give answers people prefer, a process called reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). It makes assistants far more useful, and it has a cost. Kirk and colleagues compared the stages of RLHF and found that it generalises better to new inputs but significantly reduces the diversity of outputs compared with plain supervised fine-tuning.

A controlled writing study points the same way. Padmakumar and He had people write essays alone, with a base model (GPT-3), or with a feedback-tuned model (InstructGPT). Only the feedback-tuned model produced a statistically significant drop in diversity: essays written with it were more similar to one another. The effect came mainly from the text the model contributed, not from the people.

Reason 3: different models land on the same answers

You might expect switching assistants to give you fresh ideas. The “Artificial Hivemind” study, presented at NeurIPS 2025, tested this on Infinity-Chat, a set of about 26,000 real, open-ended questions with no single correct answer. It found two things: a single model repeats itself, and different models produce strikingly similar outputs to each other. Trying a second assistant mostly gives you the first one’s ideas in different words.

Reason 4: everyone asks the same question, and the whole group loses

“Give me app ideas” is one of the most common things a new developer types. Doshi and Hauser, in Science Advances, tested what happens when many people draw on the same AI. Writers who could ask GPT-4 for starting ideas wrote stories that were rated more creative, especially the less creative writers. But the AI-assisted stories were more similar to each other. The authors call it a social dilemma: each person is better off, and the group ends up with less variety.

On Google Play this looks like the flood we describe in the AI app flood: thousands of builders reach the same idea at the same time and ship near-identical apps. The AI didn’t make a bad suggestion. It made the same good-sounding suggestion to everyone.

StudyWhat it testedWhat it found
Kirk et al., ICLR 2024Each stage of RLHF versus supervised fine-tuningRLHF generalises better but significantly reduces output diversity
Padmakumar & He, ICLR 2024Essays written alone, with GPT-3, or with InstructGPTOnly the feedback-tuned model made essays measurably more alike
Jiang et al., NeurIPS 2025~26K open-ended questions across many modelsModels repeat themselves, and different models give similar answers
Doshi & Hauser, Science Advances 2024Stories written with or without GPT-4 starting ideasMore creative one by one, more similar to each other as a group
Findings as reported in each paper’s abstract. Full references below.

What the sameness costs you on Google Play

An idea that comes from the average AI answer is an idea many other people are building, and the apps already in that space have a head start. In our study of 1,950 Google Play top-20 listings, only 1% of apps with fewer than 100 ratings reached the top 3, while apps with 100,000+ ratings did so 24% of the time (rating vs ranking study). Entering a crowded idea means competing against that gap.

The same data shows where the openings are. In our India vs US study, the same 50 searches had a different #1 app in half the cases, and India’s results followed local vocabulary: EMI calculators for “loan calculator”, GST billing apps for “invoice maker”. Local words and local needs are exactly what an average answer averages out.

Five ways to get ideas the average prompt won’t

  1. Start from demand, not imagination. Type a seed word into Google Play search and read the suggestions: those are things real people type. A suggestion with few good apps behind it is worth a closer look.
  2. Mine the complaints. Open the 1–3 star reviews of the leading app in a category and list what people say it gets wrong. An unmet need written in a customer’s own words is not in anyone’s brainstorm list.
  3. Give the model your own data. Paste in the complaints, the search suggestions and your own situation, and ask it to work on those. It is much better at analysing what you give it than at inventing from nothing.
  4. Change who and where. Ask for ideas for a specific profession, language or country (see the India examples above) instead of “app ideas”. Every constraint you add moves the answer away from the most typical one.
  5. Throw away the first ten. When you ask for 30 ideas, the early ones are the most likely ones. Read the last twenty first. (This is a practical habit, not a research finding.)
Example — The same request, with and without your own input
Before

Give me 10 app ideas.

After

I run a small physiotherapy clinic in Pune. Here are 15 complaints from my patients between sessions [paste them]. Group them, then for the three biggest groups tell me what the top 5 existing Play Store apps get wrong, based on these 1–3 star review excerpts [paste them].

Why it works. The second prompt contains information the model cannot average away: a real person, a real place and real complaints. The answer can only be about that.

Run the test yourself in ten minutes

The studies above measured this at scale, but it is easy to see on your own screen.

  1. Open five new chats with the same assistant and send each: “Give me 10 app ideas.”
  2. Write down every idea and count how many appear in three or more of the five lists.
  3. Repeat with a second assistant. Compare the two sets.
  4. Now add one real constraint, such as a profession and a country, and run it five more times. Count again.
Do
  • +Use AI to expand, sort and challenge ideas you found from real searches and reviews.
  • +Check how crowded the idea is on Google Play before you build: search it and read the top 10’s rating counts.
  • +Look for the version of the idea your own country, language or profession needs.
Don’t
  • −Treat an idea as validated because an AI suggested it. Thousands of other people got the same suggestion.
  • −Switch assistants hoping for different ideas. The research found models converge on similar answers.
  • −Build a general app in a space where the leaders have hundreds of thousands of ratings.
Read next · Industry · 7 minThe AI app flood: what vibe coding did to the app stores in 2026The other side of this story: what the sameness did to the app stores.Read next · ASO · 7 minShorter niches, smaller apps: why micro-niche apps are winning in 2026Why small, specific apps are the way out of the crowd.
Questions
Why does ChatGPT give the same app ideas every time?+

A language model produces the most probable answer, and for “give me app ideas” the most probable answers are the ideas people have written about most. Tuning for helpful replies reduces variety further. Research on tuned models found measurably less diverse output than their untuned counterparts.

Do ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini give the same app ideas?+

Often similar ones. A NeurIPS 2025 study on about 26,000 open-ended questions found that different models produce strikingly similar outputs to each other, as well as repeating themselves. Expect overlap, not an independent second opinion.

Does raising the temperature fix it?+

It can add variety within one model, but it doesn’t change what the model has learned to consider likely, and the research above found sameness across different models too. You get more randomness, not necessarily better or more original ideas.

Are AI app ideas bad?+

No. They are a reasonable starting point and useful for expanding or challenging an idea. The risk is treating them as validation: an idea many people received is an idea many people are building.

How do I find app ideas that aren’t crowded?+

Start from real demand and real complaints: Google Play search suggestions, 1–3 star reviews of the leading apps, and needs specific to a profession, language or country. Then check the competition on Google Play before you build.

Sources

  1. 01Jiang et al., “Artificial Hivemind: The Open-Ended Homogeneity of Language Models (and Beyond)”, NeurIPS 2025
  2. 02Doshi & Hauser, “Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content”, Science Advances 10(28), 2024
  3. 03Padmakumar & He, “Does Writing with Language Models Reduce Content Diversity?”, ICLR 2024
  4. 04Kirk et al., “Understanding the Effects of RLHF on LLM Generalisation and Diversity”, ICLR 2024
  5. 05ASODrift: what rating do you need to rank in Google Play’s top 10 (1,950 listings)
  6. 06ASODrift: Google Play India vs US, the same 50 searches

Specifications and figures are as published by Google and the listed sources at the time of writing (17 Nov 2026); check Play Console for the latest.

Keep readingAll articles →
Free for 1 app · 5 keywords
No card needed
Start free